ClaimPilot

HomeQuestionsCan you make an insurance claim if the accident was your fault?

Can you make an insurance claim if the accident was your fault?

Asked by Hannah_R · 2 answers · 21 June 2026

Top answerAlice T· ClaimPilot editorial22

Yes — as long as you have comprehensive cover. Comprehensive insurance covers damage to your own vehicle even when the accident was your fault. You’ll pay your excess, and your no-claims discount will usually be affected (protected no-claims limits the impact but doesn’t erase the claim from your record). If you only have third-party (or third-party, fire and theft) cover, you can’t claim for your own car’s damage in an at-fault accident — that cover only pays for damage you cause to others. So: comprehensive + at fault = you can claim, minus excess and no-claims impact. Always still report the incident to your insurer even if you decide not to claim.

Dave R.· driver3

Worth checking your excess first. On a minor at-fault scrape, the excess plus losing my no-claims meant paying out of pocket was cheaper.

Not sure about a claim before you submit it?

ClaimPilot checks your UK insurance claim the way an assessor would — flagging the gaps and wording that could get it delayed or refused — so you can fix them before you submit.

Check your claim free →

General information, not financial or legal advice. For free, impartial help see Citizens Advice or the Financial Ombudsman Service.

Can you make an insurance claim if the accident was your fault? — ClaimPilot